| 1st Period Play-by-Play |
| | End of period [45:00]. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| [41:34] | Shot by JCU Mariusz Trzeciak WIDE. |
| [41:14] | JCU substitution: Trenton Guy for Thor Erikson. |
| [40:45] | Shot by ONU Keegan Ross, SAVE Carl Contrascier. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| [39:03] | ONU substitution: Michael Grossnickle for Nate Bascom. |
| | *took pass and beat keeper to lower right |
| Ohio Northern 2, John Carroll 0 |
| [39:00] | GOAL by ONU Keegan Ross, Assist by Nate Bascom, goal number 19 for season. |
| [38:11] | Yellow card on JCU Liam Switalski. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| [37:55] | Yellow card on JCU Thor Erikson. |
| | *bicycle kick into lower right from top of box |
| Ohio Northern 1, John Carroll 0 |
| [37:55] | GOAL by ONU Chris Matejka (FIRST GOAL), goal number 6 for season. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| [36:07] | Offside against Ohio Northern. |
| | Corner kick by ONU Chris Matejka [35:59]. |
| [35:45] | Shot by ONU Shintaroh Itoh, SAVE Carl Contrascier. |
| | Corner kick by ONU Chris Matejka [35:07]. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| [33:28] | JCU substitution: Matt Brodman for Michael Melfi. |
| [33:24] | Shot by JCU Thor Erikson WIDE. |
| [32:49] | Shot by ONU Chris Matejka, SAVE Carl Contrascier. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| [31:52] | Shot by JCU Mariusz Trzeciak, SAVE Mac Church. |
| [31:21] | Shot by JCU Brian Potocnik BLOCKED. |
| | Foul on Ohio Northern. |
| [29:33] | Shot by ONU Cameron Johnson WIDE. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| | Foul on Ohio Northern. |
| [27:37] | JCU substitution: Jon Smola for Nathan Sharbaugh. |
| [27:37] | ONU substitution: Chuck D'Imperio for Chase Mueller. |
| [25:56] | Shot by JCU Nathan Sharbaugh BLOCKED. |
| | Foul on Ohio Northern. |
| [24:07] | Shot by JCU Mariusz Trzeciak, SAVE Mac Church. |
| | Corner kick by JCU Brian Potocnik [24:00]. |
| | Foul on Ohio Northern. |
| [21:12] | ONU substitution: Stephen Perkins for Jeremy Barnes. |
| [21:12] | ONU substitution: Chad Smith for Josh Green. |
| [18:59] | Shot by ONU Keegan Ross HIGH. |
| | Corner kick by ONU Chris Matejka [18:53]. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| | Corner kick by JCU Brian Potocnik [09:28]. |
| | Foul on John Carroll. |
| [01:22] | Shot by ONU OWN GOAL, SAVE Carl Contrascier. |
| [00:00] | Mac Church at goalie for Ohio Northern. |
| [00:00] | Carl Contrascier at goalie for John Carroll. |